Emergent Scholarship Matrix

Building Through Comparison

Recognizing the Path of Scholarship Through Research

In the Edutechnicalities podcast with Martin Weller, he identifies five trends and future topics in the future of scholarship, and suggests academia apply these trends towards Ernest Boyer's domains of scholarship to see examples of where this work is currently happening (and track its future progress). Here is one example of such a matrix...these scholarship examples seek to reach across academic disciplines as well as spaces of formal, informal and non-formal learning.

Mainstream of Technology in Scholarship

Scholarship Type Engagement Example Scholastic Production
Scholarship of Discovery Social Network Analysis Huang - Social Network Site Use and Academic Achievement: A Meta-Analysis
Scholarship of Teaching & Learning Social Media Construction in Learning Kozinets, Gretzel & Dinhopl - Self in Art/Self As Art: Museum Selfies As Identity Work
Scholarship of Engagement Science Diplomacy Ollivier-Mrejen, Michel & Pham - Chronicles of a Science Diplomacy Initiative on Climate Change
Scholarship of Integration Digital Humanities Brannock, Carey & Inman - Starting from the Archives: Digital Humanities Partnerships, Projects, and Pedagogies

Openness & Transparency in Scholarship

Scholarship Type Engagement Example Scholastic Production
Scholarship of Discovery Open Science Pre-Prints Kaiser - Are preprints the future of biology? A survival guide for scientists (historical review)
Scholarship of Teaching & Learning Adoption & Revision of OER Wiley & Hilton - Defining OER-Enabled Pedagogy
Scholarship of Engagement Knowledge Construction in Wikipedia Byrne & Johnston - Wikipedia: Medium and Model of Collaborative Public Diplomacy
Scholarship of Integration Sharing of Data Sets Martone, Garcia-Castro & VanderBos - Data Sharing in Psychology

Emerging Policy for Scholarship

Scholarship Type Engagement Example Scholastic Production
Scholarship of Discovery Government Publication of Data Sandoval-Almazán et al - Open Government: Open Data & Projects
Scholarship of Teaching & Learning OER Development in Tenure/Promotion/Review Thoms, Burns & Thoms - Investigating Open Education and Promotion & Tenure in the United States
Scholarship of Engagement Government Funded Research Published as Open Attard, Orlandi, Scerri & Auer - A Systematic Review of Open Government Data Initiatives
Scholarship of Integration Flexibility of Learning Units Pereira et al - Criteria-Based Assessment in a Norm-Based World: How Can We Move Past Grades?

Networked Identity

Scholarship Type Engagement Example Scholastic Production
Scholarship of Discovery Impact of Digital Identity Stewart - In Abundance: Networked Participatory Practices as Scholarship
Scholarship of Teaching & Learning Personal Learning Networks in Professional Development Couros - Developing Personal Learning Networks for Open & Social Learning
Scholarship of Engagement 'Writing Months' (NaNoWriMo, DigiWriMo, AcAdWriMo) Friend, Morris & Stommel - Writing at Scale: Composition MOOCs and Digital Writing Communities
Scholarship of Integration Synergy Through Networked Practice Veletsianos - Social Media in Academia: Networked Scholars

Criticality of Educational Technology

Scholarship Type Engagement Example Scholastic Production
Scholarship of Discovery Understanding Technology Ideologies Veletsianos & Moe - The Rise of Educational Technology as a Sociocultural & Ideological Phenomenon
Scholarship of Teaching & Learning Student Ownership of Learning Data Amirault & Visser - Electronic Data and the eLearner: Privacy, Ownership, Lifespan, Accessibility & Other Challenges
Scholarship of Engagement Open Peer Review Ford - Advancing an Open Ethos with Open Peer Review
Scholarship of Integration Digital Redlining Impact Gilliard & Culik - Digital Redlining, Access & Privacy